Sheffield Restaurant Reviews (Page 44)


+  Write a Review 


The opinions expressed on this page were not written by and are not the opinions of Sheffield Restaurant Guide. We accept no responsibility for their content.

Cerrone's (Ecclesfield) - Beverley Bailey -

Rating:

I have eaten here on a number of occasions with friends and would definitely recommend this place. The food is fantastic, with large portions, and the chocolate bread and butter pudding is a must-try.

Staff and chef very friendly and helpful.


We have 26 reviews of Cerrone's.

Cerrone's (Ecclesfield) - Rachel -

Rating:

Had one of the best meals there last week. Staff very helpful and the food is great, big portions and all cooked fresh to order.

Will definitely eat there again and highly recommend a visit, whatever the occasion.

First class.


We have 26 reviews of Cerrone's.

Whitby's (Rotherham) - Gillian -

Rating:

We have been to Whitby's many times and it's always been perfect. Staff are always attentive and very pleasant.

Just brilliant. Keep up the good work.


We have 29 reviews of Whitby's.

Elmwood Farm (Beighton) - Paul Waineright -

Rating:

Only found out about this place last weekend. I've been twice now and what can I say? The food was fantastic and the desserts have to be seen to be believed. This is definitely my new restaurant to eat in.


We have 42 reviews of Elmwood Farm.

Swan (Ridgeway) - Susan Bale -

Rating:

I attended my sister's birthday meal at your establishment on Saturday the 7th January and would like to give you my review.

We waited 50 minutes for our meals to come and were very disappointed with what we were served! I ordered the steak and mushroom pie, which was swamped in gravy and had 3 pieces of meat and quite a lot of mushrooms. The pastry was not cooked properly. All in all it was the worst meal I have had there for quite a while!


We have 18 reviews of Swan.

Beijing City (Greenhill) - Charles Stafford -

Rating:

What a way to spend our family celebration! Little communication in English with staff led to incorrect meals. Plenty of attention, but for expensive drinks orders. Lots of noise and running around by staff's children. Why do they need a storage table next to ours?

All in all what a difference a change of ownership makes!


We have 17 reviews of Beijing City.

Beijing City (Greenhill) - Diane Chapman -

Rating:

I was very disappointed the last time I went to Beijing city. I've been going regularly since the day it opened, and the food and the service was always excellent. But I'm afraid since Rachel and Peter have finished there I have nothing good to say about it. The food was cold and not up to the same standard. The service was slow and unfriendly. Rachel made everybody feel welcome. Not now. I will not be going back again unless I hear that Rachel and Peter are back.


We have 17 reviews of Beijing City.

Zagato (Aston) - Irene -

Rating:

Went to a Christmas dinner dance on 16th December. Hundreds of people packed in to a room more like a 1950s school dining hall - lots of long tables in rows. Dinner service due for 7:30pm. It was 8pm when our table got served. It was another hour, 9pm, before main course and a further three quarters of an hour before dessert.

Coffee was not served, we had to go help ourselves. Not an easy process for hundreds of people to get to two little coffee dispensers! Bar service was dreadful. Four staff who didn't appear to have any knowledge of bar skills. I had to take an empty bottle to bar to show them what I wanted! To add to that one till that the staff either didn't know how to use or it wasn't working properly.

We did complain at the time about the bar service but the management didn't want know!

Verdict - food edible, wine extortionate, and service dreadful. Won't be visiting again. Best Western Plus? I don't think so.

Went to Best Western in Newmarket two weeks previously. Service there had been brilliant. Aston Hall needs a major wake up call.


This is the first review of Zagato.

Canton Orchard (Ranmoor) - Sarah -

Rating:

We called during the day to book a table for three, and were told to just turn up.

When we arrived all the doors were locked. Another party turned up after us, at which time the manager opened the doors (this was 7PM even though it states the restaurant is open from 5PM), so we walked in and asked for a table for three, to then be shouted at and told that he was only opening up for the family behind us, and proceeded to ignore us and welcome them in.

Obviously confused about what was happening, we waited to basically be told by the manager to leave in VERY VERY rude terms, all of this in front of the other family, who looked shocked at how he was behaving. Not only was the way we were treated unacceptable from a business, but also a personal level.

We will never eat there again and will make sure everyone knows what service we received. Shame that you cannot give a rating of zero. This place doesn't deserve customers.


We have 17 reviews of Canton Orchard.

Cerrone's (Ecclesfield) - Adele Richards -

Rating:

Been a few times last year, not one bad meal. Love the 2-for-1 nights, they're a fab evening out with friends. Will be booking shortly.


We have 26 reviews of Cerrone's.

Cerrone's (Ecclesfield) - Nigel Muddiman -

Rating:

Delays in writing a review, as we visited just before Christmas 2016 and we stumbled across a 2-for-1 night, having never visited before.

It was very busy, due to Christmas as well, but the staff were superb and very, very organised. Found them all to be very hardworking, helpful and sociable, which was a pleasure.

The food was excellent, too, to the point where my partner and I both agreed we'd visit again on both the offers nights but also other nights, too.

Thanks a lot... loved the warm, friendly atmosphere, and I thanked the chefs for their efforts, as we were very impressed.


We have 26 reviews of Cerrone's.

Fairways Inn (Birley Wood) - Jean -

Rating:

Christmas dinner - this was a glorified carvery at an over-inflated price.

The sprouts were overcooked & the darkest green I have ever seen. The meat, you could only have what they put on your plate, only one Yorkshire pud (very small frozen type), and one small sausage with no bacon on them. Some of the starters were still frozen in middle. The best bit was the trifle.

The room we were in was overcrowded.


We have 30 reviews of Fairways Inn.

Castle Inn (Bradway) - Paul Bromley -

Rating:

We had a disappointing visit the last time we went to the Castle, when we were outside around 10pm drinking our drinks a member of staff decided to noisily stack all the chairs from around us, as we were the only people outside.

We went last night, as it was New Year's Eve. Very expensive drinks and a few miserable and rude members of staff almost spoiled it for us. Lovely decor though, I won't be returning and I sadly as a local hope they close their doors for good. I will not be risking another visit.


We have 5 reviews of Castle Inn.

Whitby's (Rotherham) - Roberts -

Rating:

Tasteless and greasy fish and chips. Chips were all dried and bitty. Foreign object found in my mushy peas. Our coffees and one portion of peas and chips refunded.

Was very disappointed, won't be returning. Will stick with Wetherby Whaler in Wakefield, they do know how to make good fish & chips.


We have 29 reviews of Whitby's.

Viraaj (Woodseats) - Lee Tyler -

Rating:

Love this restaurant, the service is excellent and the staff are very polite and welcoming.


We have 4 reviews of Viraaj.

Crown & Cushion (Chapeltown) - Janet Askham -

Rating:

Just been to the Crown & Cushion for lunch with some members of my family. I had a two courses from the 60s and over menu (unfortunately I qualify!). I had the duck and orange pate for starter, which was very tasty, and for the main I had the battered cod, chips, and mushy peas.

What a treat to eat home-cooked chips instead of the frozen rubbish. They were delicious and reminded me of my mum's.

My daughter had the gammon, which was so large she couldn't finish it, and my sister-in-law had the liver, which again she couldn't finish.

I expected the place to be very busy, so surprisingly it was fairly quiet so there was a nice comfortable atmosphere.

I have been several times and have yet to have a bad meal. Keep up the good work Crown and Cush!


We have 14 reviews of Crown & Cushion.

Meadow Farm (Ecclesfield) - Pat Beaumont -

Rating:

Our second Christmas dinner at Meadow Farm. Once again we were not disappointed. The meal was served really quickly, it was hot and plentiful and delicious. The staff were really helpful and couldn't do enough for us. Definitely would recommend.

Thank you all Meadow Farm staff for a lovely time.


We have 40 reviews of Meadow Farm.

Amraj (Beighton) - Anne Monks -

Rating:

My husband and I visited the Amraj restaurant for the first time just before Christmas and were extremely pleased with everything, from the food, which was amazing, to the gorgeous décor and friendliness of the staff. We could not have been made more welcome. The food is all made from fresh ingredients and is made to order. We were also helped with our choice of food and given advice regarding how spicy or not the food was.

We had a very enjoyable experience and will definitely be returning in the near future!


We have 12 reviews of Amraj.