Sheffield Restaurant Reviews (Page 2)

+  Write a Review 

The opinions expressed on this page were not written by and are not the opinions of Sheffield Restaurant Guide. We accept no responsibility for their content.

Whitby's (Rotherham) - Vanessa -


Gone downhill to say they're only serving one customer at a time. Chips were either bad or scraps. Not be going again.

We have 23 reviews of Whitby's.

Jumeirah Spice (Ecclesfield) - Tariq Mahmood -


One of the best traditional Indian restaurants. Chefs are from curry capital, Bradford. Try nehaari lamb shanks - melt in your mouth. 7-star like the Jumeirah in Dubai.

We have 8 reviews of Jumeirah Spice.

La Perle (Wicker) - Brad -


Nice guy, which is even more disappointing that he's just served me a total off cake. The entire base of the lemon cheese cake was black smelts really bad and was not possible to see. Disappointed to say the least. The man couldn't not have seen this while putting both pieces into the box, not to mention this cake has likely been sat their for the majority of lockdown as couldn't not be off.

We have 5 reviews of La Perle.

Mangla (Burngreave) - Maxine Kerry -


I've been going to this restaurant over 20 years. Tonight 16/01/21 at 6:30 I ordered a takeaway, which they said would be here by 7:33. At 8:10 I rang for them to say it's done we're just waiting for a delivery driver. OK 8:40 I rang again for them to tell me they're still waiting for a delivery driver but not to worry, my order has been done and waiting since 8:02.

Finally at 9:14 my order was here, which was freezing cold. To be fair the salad was warmer.

Very disappointed. After 20 years of custom I will definitely not be returning to this place never again.

We have 6 reviews of Mangla.

India Garden (Heeley) - Teresa Kemp -


Just ordered a collection from here and we only live 5 minutes away but the food was cold. The onion bhajis were rock hard and the nans bread were not even warm.

What a waste a of £26. We have been here and had takeaways before but this is the worst.

Will not be going here again.

We have 6 reviews of India Garden.

Carluccio's (Meadowhall Shopping Centre) - Andy F -


I am flabbergasted by the reviews below, giving just one star. We eat at Carluccio's regularly, when open, and have never had a bad meal or bad service. In fact the service is exceptional and the food immaculate. We have not had an issue with dirty anything.

We have only ever had one problem, the non-arrival of a side dish. We waited until our lovely server came by next and pointed it out to her. The issue was dealt with immediately.

I feel like the reviewers below have really been spoilt if they think Carluccio's Meadowhall is poor.

We have 6 reviews of Carluccio's.

Whitby's (Rotherham) - Mark -


Fish and chips good but so so slow serving.

Come on guys there's one bloke serving inside and a massive queue outside. It's only fish n chips, should take a couple of minutes to do an order.

Sat in the car while my partner queued up and could see the one server leisurely chatting inside.

We have 23 reviews of Whitby's.

Akash (Kiveton Park) - Rachael Lees -


Worst curry ever, and I mean ever. My daughter ordered this and I only tasted it. It all went in the bin. Absolutely disgusting.

What made it worse is the very rude member of staff who spoke to my daughter. His manners where appalling . Would not give out his name, should not work in customer service. Kept trying to fob her off saying she needed to phone the manager then when she phoned the manager the following day he was conveniently off having an op.


We have 3 reviews of Akash.

ASK Italian (City Centre) - Roger and Heather Atterton -


My wife and I had meal at ASK, Cambridge Street, on 29 Oct 2020.

The meal and wine was exceptionally good and the service provided by Michelle and Daniel was great.

We have 9 reviews of ASK Italian.

Dos Amigos (Woodseats) - Violet -


Nothing on the menu was remotely Mexican, not even any spices, seasoning or ingredients. Baffled why there's so many Mexican-Italian places here... you don't see any Japanese-Swedish or Spanish-German restaurants, do you? I can't make sense of why they lump Mexican and Italian together. But it's neither, anyway.

Here, just as in nearly every "Mexican" restaurant in the UK, overly sweet Italian inspired sauces + British sauces are mixed with Middle Eastern and South Asian seasonings/ingredients in truly odd dishes that aren't Mexican or even Italian really.

British folks may enjoy this, but for me it was inedible. Odd dishes that don't go together and are not representative of any cuisine style, underseasoned, mushy, bland. I'd give it zero stars if I could. If you like Mexican food, steer clear.

Also there isn't a single person of Mexican or Italian descent working here.

This is the first review of Dos Amigos.

Akash (Kiveton Park) - Sean -


Ordered our curry, which took a reasonable 40 minutes to arrive, only to find a tasteless, watery waste of £23. Probably the worst curry I've had in 20 years!

We have 3 reviews of Akash.

Taybarns (Tankersley) - Paul Gorman -


Taybarns no longer operates here. The restaurant is now a Brewers fare.

Having just been here I can honestly say that we were served by a very respectable young woman. Obviously they have reduced tables so as to observe Covid-19 regulations. The meals were very good and the prices are very good for the various typical pub meal menu. We were able to sterilise our hands as often as we wished and the waitress did not touch our cutlery or plates etc. when delivering to the table.

We will be back again soon.

We have 9 reviews of Taybarns.

ASK Italian (City Centre) - Hope -


We ordered via Uber Eats expecting proper Italian-style pizza. We were all so let down by the quality. All 4 pizzas were bland, dry, and the cheese was very rubbery. I don't think we would bother again unfortunately.

We have 9 reviews of ASK Italian.

Smoke Barbecue (City Centre) - John -


Avoid this place like the plague.

My wife was involved in a major car accident an hour before our table booking so I contacted the restaurant to cancel our booking because she was upset, shaken and in pain.

A manager by the of Chantell finally spoke to me on the telephone after requesting several times to speak to the manager after they refused the £15 reimbursement we paid for our table booking.

Smoke, including the manager, couldn't have cared less about our situation and were uncaring and unhelpful.

She refused to give me her manager's name and just kept on saying I don't care about your accident only our terms and conditions.

Shocking company, employees and customer service.

We have 18 reviews of Smoke Barbecue.

Elmwood Farm (Beighton) - Heather -


Went for Sunday lunch at Elmwood Farm, Sheffield. Very disappointed. Had to wait ages for drinks. Waiter said he would be back in 2 minutes; he never returned. When drinks finally arrived, coffee was cold, cup was very dirty, had to be returned.

The only thing the staff were interested in was your bank card, which had to be swiped as soon as you walked though the door.

Service very poor, food worse, all the Sunday lunches were cold. Just glad when I left the building. That was the only good thing I can say about the place, the exit doors.

Will never waste money there again.

We have 27 reviews of Elmwood Farm.

Sword Dancer (Handsworth) - Daniel Wild -


Went in yesterday for a light lunch and was disappointed to be told they had no baguettes or wraps. I then heard the staff telling other customers when taking their order that they had no salad, burgers or bread for toast!

Asda and Aldi are both less than 5 mins walk!

We have 32 reviews of Sword Dancer.