Sheffield Restaurant Reviews (Page 3)

  If you would like to review a restaurant in Sheffield, please use our submit a review page.

The reviews contained on this page were not written by and are not the opinions of Sheffield Restaurant Guide. We accept no responsibility for their content.

Ambar Tandoori Restaurant (Ecclesall) - Del Siggs - 11th January 2013

Rating:

Regular user of this restaurant. Definitely the best Indian restaurant in Sheffield. Highly recommended. Fantastic food, excellent service. Tables in the alcove are a bit cramped for tall people, but book one not in the alcove.

Butlers Balti House (City Centre) - Ali - 6th January 2013

Rating:

The best Indian I have eaten in a very long time!

The chicken saag balti special was so tasty, the chicken succulent & tender.

Excellent, friendly service and very good value!

I will definitely be back.

Cafe Rouge (Ecclesall) - Tony & Lu Hayes - 5th January 2013

Rating:

New Year's Eve, what a blast. Everyone got into the party spirit, especially Andrea and her superb crew, all dressed up and determined to party even if they had to work! As soon as you walked through the door you knew it was going to be a fun night, and it was. We didn't get to stay until the end because we had to go elsewhere. Shan't make that mistake at the next 'do', we'll be there right until the end.

What a brilliant team there, everyone works together. Cafe Rouge you should be proud and wish all your cafes were as good.

(Still needs a refurb though, that's why they don't get a 5-star rating.)

Mohul Tandoori Restaurant (Totley Brook) - Mike Connelly - 2nd January 2013

Rating:

We had a large takeaway order from Mohul on New Year's Eve and I can honestly say it was some of the worst Indian food we've ever had.

I ordered butterfly prawns. At £4.95 for a starter, it was not the cheapest. However, I got a flattened lump of breadcrumb and batter, where it was a real struggle to find anything that resembled a prawn. Had I been in the restaurant it would have been sent back. As it was it ended up in the in bin. My lamb tikka madras was a slight improvement, but not a patch on Indian food I've eaten recently at Ambar and House of Spice restaurants on Ecclesall Road.

The rest of the people in my party were equally disappointed and we all agreed it was one of the worst Indian meals we had ever eaten.

Not recommended.

Handmade Burger Co. (Meadowhall Shopping Centre) - Tom Bradwell - 27th December 2012

Rating:

The service was rubbish, the burgers dry and tasteless, and to top all that it was very over priced. Overall the worst restaurant we have ever eaten in. You would have a better meal in McDonald's downstairs!

Milestone (Shalesmoor) - Anna - 24th December 2012

Rating:

Cannot for the life of me understand these reviews. I have dined at the Milestone of four occasions, once during the day and the rest on an evening. Each time we have enjoyed some of the freshest, tastiest food we have ever eaten. I would even go so far as to say the food here is on a par with some Michelin-starred restaurants we've eaten at (and considerably better value for money). Service is relaxed and unobtrusive and the atmosphere is great.

Please don't be put off by the previous reviews, I can't recommend the Milestone enough!

Golden Lee Restaurant (Heeley) - Maria - 18th December 2012

Rating:

This use to be a really good food place since I can remember as a child. Now unfortunately it has to be one of the worst!

Waited nearly 2 hours for food and when it finally came it was one of the nastiest Chinese I've ever had.

I would not recommend Golden Lee to anyone. Such a shame!

Orient Express (City Centre) - Jodie - 16th December 2012

Rating:

Orient Express was recommended by one of the overseas students studying in Sheffield. She said many local Chinese also dine there.

The dishes are authentic, at excellent prices. The staff are very helpful and courteous.

It is the first time we have ever had Peking and Cantonese dishes, it was a wonderful experience. The menu has a very good selection to chose from.

Highly recommended.

Hei Moon (Hillsborough) - Stephanie - 7th December 2012

Rating:

Hei Moon is our local Chinese restaurant, but I think we'd happily travel if it was further away. Food is always excellent, despite the enormous menu, and staff are friendly. Recommended!

Akhtars (Killamarsh) - Chris Cooper - 7th December 2012

Rating:

This really is a review of 2 halves. We used to eat here at least once a week and often had takeaways as well. Food excellent, service very attentive and we were always looked after, hence it was a regular spot for us.

They started doing a Thursday night promotion, were Cobra was free and it fell in line nicely with a birthday party so I took a party of 12 for the night. The posters were prominently displayed both on the door going in and also on the front window of the restaurant - great offer so why not promote it!

We had a great night again yet when the bill came they'd charged us for the Cobras. I pointed out that this was free on a Thursday night and hence shouldn't be on the bill. I was told that, as we had not asked for free Cobras at the start of the night, they were chargeable. (Just to point out no mention of this on the posters.) I obviously argued this and after 15 minutes of to-ing and fro-ing and my threat that they either removed them from the bill or I wasn't paying any of it (I should point out that a certain amount of intimidation was also attempted by the staff as well) it was removed from the bill. However, for a known regular customer (actually for any customer) this was wholly inappropriate and unsatisfactory and managed to sour what should have been a great night of celebration.

The manager wasn't there on the night and I did think there was a certain amount of opportunism being shown by the under manager on the night so I went back on a subsequent occasion (not to eat) to point his out to the manager and give him an opportunity to rectify the matter. Unfortunately he simply wasn't interested and no apology was even forthcoming so we've never been back since.

I've relayed this story to a number of people now and have been surprised just how many others this has happened to.

A real shame but great benefit for another local-ish restaurant who now benefit from our custom.

Bay of Bengal (Gleadless) - Ryu - 2nd December 2012

Rating:

Really nice and helpful staff that even made a custom dish to my requirements.

Will definitely be returning again for a meal & will try the take-away service.

Cutlers Spice (Gleadless) - Karl Clayton - 2nd December 2012

Rating:

Outstanding interior followed by first class service, completed with exquisite food. Staff couldn't do enough for us. Brilliant night.

East One Noodle Bar (City Centre) - Tracey Eason - 28th November 2012

Rating:

Fantastic place, gorgeous food, great service. The food is very fresh with amazing flavours. One of my favourite places to eat. Our family in Bradford love it so much, they come all the way to Sheffield just to eat here. Love it!

Indus Restaurant (Attercliffe) - Vicky Knight - 27th November 2012

Rating:

First time to the restaurant. Tuesday buffet night. When we arrived a member of staff showed us to our table, then took us over to the food to show us what was on offer. Looked very nice and clean. Poppadoms and pickle tray we're fetched straight over and starters & salad you just helped yourself. (Onion bhaji, fish, samosa tandoori chicken.)

Mains (rice, lamb dish, 2 chicken dishes, 2 vegetarian dishes) all food nice and hot. We were asked if we wanted naan bread etc...

Staff very helpful and friendly.

Looking forward to our next visit.

El Paso (City Centre) - Karen - 22nd November 2012

Rating:

Tasty food, great service, fun atmosphere. I was recently there with a party aged from 15 to over 50 and we all had a great time.

Cutlers Spice (Gleadless) - Claire Heald - 21st November 2012

Rating:

Eating out for me is some what stressful, I have coeliac disease and find the places I go have no coeliac meals to offer. Cutlers I found to be very helpful in supporting me with my choices, even though I had to take my own nann bread they warmed it through. The manager even came over to discuss my condition and where he could purchase the breads.

I found the food to be very good, the portion size was just right, the place was well lit and the service was OK for the size of our group.

I am eating there again on the 15th December with a party of 22 an cannot wait.

Bay of Bengal (Gleadless) - Janey - 16th November 2012

Rating:

Very good food and service. Went last Wednesday night and was busy. Staff were attentive and efficient.

Would go again.

Bay of Bengal (Gleadless) - Mike and Zara - 15th November 2012

Rating:

First visit but would not be our last. Very welcoming, excellent service and nice food. Looking forward to trying the Sunday carvery and buffet night on Tuesday.

Mamma Mia Pepe (Hillsborough) - Anne Hobson - 14th November 2012

Rating:

Small, authentic, family restaurant with feel of being on holiday. Superb food (especially the slow cooked lamb), friendly service, open kitchen so you can watch the fresh pizzas being made, nice house wine. Would certainly recommend this little place. The special midweek menu is particularly good value at £9.99.

Bay of Bengal (Gleadless) - Sandra and Stuart Hill - 12th November 2012

Rating:

Thursday 8th November 2012 decided to try the Muroogh Mas-sallam Indian feast. It was well worth the notice required, as the meal was beyond our wildest expectations. The chicken fell off the bone and yet was still moist, the quantity and spicy flavours were unbelievable. We intend to try the duckling and the lamb in due course. Best Indian meal we have ever had.

More Restaurant Reviews: